Navigating the cookieless world: A guide for marketers

October 9, 2023

The internet, for all its wonder, can be a rather strange place. It's a boundless cornucopia of knowledge, where you can dive into the mysteries of quantum physics one moment and watch adorable cat videos the next. Sometimes, it seems to have the ability to predict, or read exactly what we want - even if we don’t know we want it. 

You know the experience. You're browsing the internet, checking out some sleek sneakers, maybe researching your next tropical vacation, and suddenly, it feels like those sneakers and that beachfront paradise are following you around like an overzealous personal shopper. It's not magic; it's cookies. But before you start thinking about delicious baked goods, let's dive into the digital world of cookies, what's changing, and how we, as savvy marketers, can adapt to this evolving landscape.

What are they really? 

Cookies are like the digital equivalent of those tiny messages inside fortune cookies. In fact, that’s where they got their name!  In the online world, they are small text files that store data. Imagine checking into a luxury hotel. The manager knows your preferences and past visits, ensuring a top-notch experience. Cookies do something similar for websites. They remember your information and share it with your browser, enabling the display of content tailored to your preferences and past activities.

The two types of cookies

There are two main cookie categories: first-party and third-party cookies.

First-party cookies: These cookies are created by the website you're visiting. They're unique to that site and function within it. First-party cookies serve various purposes:

  • Remembering who you are, allowing you to log in securely.
  • Keeping track of your shopping cart contents or wish list.
  • Making personalized recommendations based on your browsing history.

First-party cookies, often called "essential cookies," are supported by all browsers. Users can choose to reject them, but these cookies typically enhance the website's functionality. 

Third-party cookies: These cookies come from websites other than the one you're currently on. Think of them as your personal assistant who follows you to different places, observing your behavior and preferences. While some third-party cookies can be beneficial, they often raise privacy concerns when used by unknown entities.

Imagine the digital world as a bustling city. You're strolling down its virtual streets, visiting various online shops, reading articles, and maybe checking out a new restaurant (or two). But what you might not realize is that there's a digital detective tagging along with you, quietly taking notes on your every move. These cyber sleuths are called third-party cookies, and they're the secret agents of the internet.

Let’s use Facebook as an example. They've strategically placed their cookies, like breadcrumbs, on millions of websites across the globe through something called the Facebook pixel. As you wander this online city, these cookies diligently send little reports back to Facebook, saying things like, "Hey, this person just checked out that cool new gadget," or "They read that fascinating article on space travel."

Now, here's where it gets interesting – Facebook takes all this information and combines it with what they already know about you, creating a comprehensive dossier of your online activities. This enables Facebook to serve you ads that align perfectly with your digital footprint.

Are third-party cookies inherently bad?

Well, not exactly. Whether they're good or bad often hinges on one critical factor: permission. Imagine that the person tailing you around the virtual city is your trusted personal assistant, and you're well aware of their presence and purpose. In this scenario, having them by your side can be incredibly beneficial. They know your preferences inside out, offering suggestions and assistance tailored precisely to your liking.

However, when you're being digitally shadowed by someone you don't know, and you have no clue what they're up to with the information they're collecting – that's when things start to get a tad dicey. It's like having an unknown figure tailing you in the real world, peeking over your shoulder without your consent. In such cases, questions about privacy and security naturally arise.

Change is coming 

Third-party cookies are gradually fading into the digital sunset. In the past, they allowed for extensive tracking of user behavior across the web, enabling highly precise ad targeting. However, users are becoming more privacy-conscious, and lawmakers are tightening regulations. Google Chrome, one of the most popular web browsers, has announced plans to phase out support for third-party cookies by the end of 2023.

Impact on ad platforms

This shift has significant implications for ad platforms. With limited access to user data, platforms like Facebook or Google can't track your every move on the web anymore. The days of ultra-precise ad targeting are waning. Platforms will only track your actions directly within their ecosystems. This means they'll have less detailed insight into your interests and online activities.

What marketers can do to navigate this change

In this evolving digital landscape, what can savvy marketers do to successfully navigate these changes in the cookie landscape and continue to thrive in the world of online advertising and consumer engagement?

1. Rethinking attribution: As direct tracking becomes trickier, focus on lift and incrementality. Measure how your advertising efforts impact changes before and after campaigns. It's a broader, more holistic approach to understanding your campaign's overall impact on business growth.

2. Leveraging first-party data: While third-party cookies decline, first-party cookies are here to stay. Use them to collect data directly from users, improving attribution and reporting. You can also create customer segments based on this data for more effective ad targeting.

3. Embracing contextual targeting: With third-party cookies on the decline, contextual targeting, based on the content of the page and user activities, becomes vital. Advertisers can reach users based on their current online activities and the content they engage with.

4. Broadening targeting and creative testing: With limited user data, it's often more effective to broaden your targeting and test different ad creatives. Platforms still know which ads users click on, offering valuable data for optimization.

5. Personalization using first-party data: Use first-party data to personalize user experiences on your site. Tailor content based on their behavior, preferences, and the context of their visit. Personalization can significantly improve conversions.

6. Elevating top-of-funnel campaigns: With reduced retargeting capabilities, focus on top-of-funnel campaigns to build brand awareness. These campaigns capture users early in their journey, allowing you to collect data and personalize downstream efforts effectively.

It’s a new era of advertising 

The end of third-party cookies marks a transformative moment for marketers. It doesn't signify the end of digital advertising but rather a shift toward a more privacy-centric and individual-focused approach. Which isn’t really a bad thing, is it? 

Welcome to the cookieless world, where adaptability and innovation are the keys to success.

Are you a marketer curious to learn about the aspects that affect our industry?

Or do you want to tap into our expertise to sharpen your tactics? Look no further than our free downloadable resources. We work hard to research our content - and offer it to you - free of charge.